Concert 7. Wednesday 15 April 2015 PDF Print E-mail



two violins, cello and harpsichord

Handel and the Italians




Handel Sonata for 2 violins and continuo op. 2/5
Francesco Veracini  Sonata Scozzese in A op. 2/9 
Arcangelo Corelli     Sonata for 2 violins and continuo in D op. 4/8 
Handel  Sonata for violin and continuo in D op. 1/13          
Antonio Caldera Chiacona for 2 violins and continuo in B b op. 2/12   
Giovanni Carbonelli     Sonata for violin and continuo in G
Arcangelo Corelli Sonata for 2 violins and continuo in D op. 1/12


 An Evening of Baroque Delight at the Ilkley Concert Club


La Serenissima is a baroque specialists' collective that on this occasion sent us two violinists with cello and harpsichord continuo. Such groups go down well at early music events but do not always find favour with a more generalist audience of a concert club. It's all to do with presentation. The pieces played were cleverly chosen to give us variety of instrumentation from the full ensemble to a sonata by Handel just for violin and harpsichord. There was variety in the music selected with some welcome departures from standard baroque composers' practice, a Veracini sonata that ended with variations on a Scottish folk-song and an extended one-movement Chaconne by Caldara that acted as a foil to the succession of briefer movements in the rest of the programme.


The programme notes written by the group's leader Adrian Chandler were very informative. Supplemented by his spoken introductions before each concert item they brought the period and its composers vividly to life. He also proved to be a superb communicator with his violin, playing with real personality whilst staying true to baroque sensibilities.


His colleagues were equally adept as performers. Half the six items involved a second violin and Camilla Scarlett 's partnership with the leader was so secure that I felt it was a pity that she'd not had the chance to shine in one of the solo violin sonatas. Cellist Gareth Deats, a power-house of energy throughout was clearly having a wonderful time, as was Robert Howarth at the harpsichord. But especially when all four of them were playing I could barely hear his instrument, not his fault. Someone needs to invent a historically informed candle-powered amplifier. As a jazz-lover I wanted to hear his improvised responses to the bass-lines he'd been given.


'Not a note of Vivaldi' said Adrian at the start - how refreshing to be able to hear works by his contemporaries such as Carbonelli, whose music on the evidence of this concert is less formulaic. Thank you!



The following recordings were recommended in the concert programme


Due to the large number of items I am omitting comments for each recording. However, all the recommendations are excellent performances in good quality sound. Downloads are available.


Handel, Op.2, No.5

The Brook Street band play all the Op.2 works on Avie AV 2282 (full price).


A recital entitled "London Calling" by Barokksolistene, including works by Veracini, Corelli, Geminiani and Handel is on the BIS label, BIS-SACD-1997 (SACD/CD at full price).


Corelli, Op.4, No.8

The Avison Ensemble play all the Op.2 and Op.4 works on Linn CKD 413 (2 SACD/CDs at medium price).


Handel, Op.1, No.13

This is included on a CD of Handel Violin Sonatas by Ensemble Vintage Köln on Naxos 8.572245 (medium price).



Parnassi Musici play Trio Sonatas and Cello Sonatas by Caldara on CPO 999 871-2 (full price).



Hélène Schmitt (violin) and others play Sonatas for Violin & Basso Continuo on Alpha 046 (full price).


Corelli, Op.1, No.12

Another excellent 2 disc set from The Avison Ensemble, who play Op.1 and Op.3 on Linn CDK 414 (2 SACD/CDs at medium price).

Raymond Waud.


Club Notes for this concert


If you as a Member have not already expressed your opinion about the start time for our concerts, then there is still time. The Committee will make the decision after tonight's concert. The consultation will close on 17th April 2015 and I will announce the Committee's decision at the May concert.

To update the information from the March concert's Club Notes:

• Email your opinion to This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it or

• Mail your opinion to me at Flat 2, Skelda Grange, Wells Road, Ilkley LS29 9JE or

• Leave a note with your opinion at the March or April concerts. There will be Boxes labelled "Concert Start Time Consultation" in the Winter Garden, both upstairs and downstairs.

In all cases be sure to give your Name (clearly please) so we know if the opinions apply to one or two seat holders.


I was quite sure that I had written a Club Note about Arthur Butterworth, who died at the age of 91 last November, but looking back I see I did not. Ilkley Concert Club Members will remember his contribution to David Pyett's Celebration Concert, when his composition "Tarka" was given its first performance. Neither Geoffrey Kinder nor I (David Wharmby) had met Arthur before we commissioned "Tarka" on behalf of ICC. We both came away from that discussion feeling honoured to have met such a remarkable man. Several obituaries in the National Press confirm that our response was not unusual, as did the large number of people attending his woodland burial on a snowy, cold but sunny day last December. His contribution to music, and especially local music was immense. "Tarka" is the only other piece that has the same instrumentation as Copland's "Appalachian Spring", so we can hope that in the future it will have the many performances that it deserves.


David Pyett tells me that another local composer Patric Standford "a very nice man" who has connections with ICC died in April this year. In 2005 his "Five French Folksongs for wind quintet" was performed by the Nash Ensemble.